The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping
Murray Close/Lionsgate

VERDICT: The games themselves still provide thrills and tension, but the plotting in this latest franchise entry falls prey to prequel predictability.

The original Hunger Games franchise represented a near-ideal version of the popcorn movie with something to say: amidst the photogenic young people fighting for their lives and the extravagant decadence of futuristic income inequality, the films (and the Suzanne Collins YA novels on which they were based) taught a generation of fans about totalitarianism, class struggle, and propaganda. With the second prequel to The Hunger Games, Sunrise on the Reaping, it’s clear that the series has exhausted every point it ever wanted to make. All that’s left is more fighting, and lots of fan service involving younger versions of established characters meeting for the first time.

The focus is Haymitch Abernathy, the Games’ first champion from impoverished District 12,  a player who would later become an essential mentor and coach in the original films, where he was portrayed by Woody Harrelson; Joseph Zada (Netflix’s East of Eden) takes on the role in this story, set nearly a quarter-century before the first Hunger Games movie. Padem’s deadly competition — setting children and teenagers against each other in a fight to the finish, to punish a quashed revolution and to distract an oppressed populace — is celebrating its 50th go-round, and Haymitch winds up being drafted alongside the much-younger Louella (Molly McCann), haughty merchant’s daughter Maysilee (Mckenna Grace), and Wyatt Callow (Ben Wang), whose family runs a bookmaking operation among the miners of the district.

Sunrise on the Reaping has the narrative shape of most Hunger Games movies: tributes are selected and sent to the capital, they train for the games and try to win over the TV audience, they fight for their lives and do what they can to push back against the oppressive government of Panem. Since it’s a prequel, the movie constantly lets the audience know that it knows that they know: who these characters are, what they’re about to do, and what they will eventually mean to each other. This front-loaded situation prompts scene after scene in which actors do their best to impersonate their counterparts from the earlier movies — Jesse Plemons works toward Philip Seymour Hoffman as Plutarch Heavensbee, Elle Fanning summons the spirit of Elizabeth Banks as Effie Trinket, and so on, and so on. There are also multiple instances of Haymitch announcing that he doesn’t drink, nudging the audience in the ribs, as any fan still showing up for this round of movies knows that the later version of the character is an abject alcoholic.

What turned this teetotaler into a drinker is the narrative agenda here, and for audiences sufficiently invested in this world and its inhabitants, that may well be enough. Those less committed to the series may wonder what the point is, although returning director Francis Lawrence, director of all but the first of the series, keeps the games themselves unsettlingly violent and unpredictable. (Well, as unpredictable as they can be, given that we know Haymitch has to win.)

Production designer Uli Hanisch (Cloud Atlas) serves up the vivid contrasts between the Appalachian-inspired District 12 (a mix of pastoral meadows and industrial blight) and the gleaming capital; the tributes train in Berlin’s Congress Center, summoning a sleek future as effectively as it did back in 1980’s The Apple. The cinematography by Jo Willems (The Long Walk) provides the necessary contrasting light, differentiating the horrors of the characters’ real lives and the glitz served up by the television cameras.

Zada and Whitney Peak (as Haymitch’s true love Lenore Dove Baird) provide the emotional heft to their few scenes together — they spend most of the film apart, but their relationship is key to his backstory — and Grace and Wang each grab a few moments within their second-banana roles, but the overall impression of The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is that rarely has a cast this talented been tasked with so little. Almost every adult speaking role has been assigned to one of this generation’s leading performers, but whether it’s Ralph Fiennes as President Snow or Maya Hawke and Lili Taylor as the coaches for District 12’s fighters, they barely register.

The Hunger Games has always rewarded its hammiest turns — think Elizabeth Banks, Stanley Tucci, and Jason Schwartzman in previous installments — and Kieran Culkin and Glenn Close (in prosthetics that suggest Katharine Helmond in Brazil) chew the scenery without hesitation. So does Billy Porter, as a fashion designer eventually usurped by Effie Trinket, but his screen time is so minimal as to be an afterthought.

Collins and her adapters are certainly entitled to keep this lucrative franchise alive, but if Sunrise on the Reaping (and its predecessor, The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes) are any indication, they’ve run out of new ideas. The Hunger Games once boasted a sense of urgency and essential metaphor; now they’re just taking a victory lap. And as a heartbroken Haymitch would agree, winning doesn’t necessarily mean succeeding.

Director: Francis Lawrence
Screenwriters: Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie, based on the novel by Suzanne Collins
Cast: Joseph Zada, Jesse Plemons, Ralph Fiennes, Glenn Close, Kieran Culkin, Elle Fanning, Mckenna Grace, Maya Hawke, Whitney Peak, Kelvin Harrison Jr., Ben Wang, Billy Porter, Molly McCann, Iona Bell, Lili Taylor, Percy Daggs IV, Iris Apatow, Edvin Ryding, Rada Rae, Laura Marcus
Executive producers: Suzanne Collins, Mika Saito, Cameron MacConomy
Producers: Nina Jacobson, Brad Simpson, Francis Lawrence
Director of photography: Jo Willems
Production design: Uli Hanisch
Editing: Mark Yoshikawa
Music: James Newton Howard
Sound design: Jeremy Peirson, re-rec0rding mixer/sound designer/supervising sound editor
Production companies: Lionsgate, Color Force, about:blank
In English
158 minutes